Skip to main content

Green Witchcraft: Plants, Seasons and Working With the Land

Green Witchcraft: Plants, Seasons and Working With the Land - low-poly illustration of witchcraft themes on DailyDestiny

Green witchcraft is a plant-centered path in which a green witch grows, forages and works with the flora of one specific place rather than with imported correspondences. This guide covers the core green witch herbs, foraging ethics and law, planning a working garden, marking the seasons by phenology, and how green witchcraft differs from hedge and kitchen practice.

What is green witchcraft, and what does a green witch do day to day?

Green witchcraft is a plant-centered witchcraft path in which the working partners are living plants and one specific piece of ground, rather than a pantheon or a fixed ritual liturgy. A green witch learns the flora within walking distance, grows what they can, forages what they cannot, dries and preserves the harvest, and builds spellwork from that material instead of from a bought kit. Day to day the practice looks unremarkable from outside. Checking whether the elder has set flower. Cutting mugwort before it goes woody. Turning a jar of calendula petals in oil on the windowsill. Pulling bindweed off the hedge at the end of the lane. The magical content sits inside those actions rather than beside them, which is the whole point. Green witchcraft treats sustained attention as the primary technique. A green witch who knows that the hawthorn at the field gate flowers eleven days later than the one in the churchyard holds information no printed correspondence table can supply, and that information is what the craft actually runs on. Natural witchcraft is the older label for the same approach and it names the emphasis exactly: the work is done with what grows here, not with imported symbolism. There is no initiation and no required deity. There is a standard of competence, which is that you can name what you are holding.

The green witch label is modern, but the material is not. Village herb-wives, cunning folk, and country healers across Europe worked from the same premise, that the useful plants are the local ones and that a practitioner is judged on results and identification. The modern reassembly of that material into a named path happened largely through publishing. Ann Moura's Green Witchcraft, issued by Llewellyn from 1996, framed it inside a family witchcraft religion, and Arin Murphy-Hiscock's The Green Witch presented a version that assumes no theology at all. The two books disagree about deity and agree about almost everything else, which tells you where the center of gravity sits. What distinguishes green witchcraft from generic herb use is reciprocity. Plants are treated as parties to the work rather than as ingredients, so a green witch asks before cutting, leaves the first and the last, tends what they take from, and counts a harvest that damages a stand as a failed working regardless of what the spell produced. That ethic is the operating rule that keeps a green witch practice viable in the same square mile for decades.

Is green witchcraft a religion, and does a green witch need a deity?

Green witchcraft is a practice rather than a religion, and a green witch needs no deity to work. Some address named gods, some address land spirits or the plants themselves, and many address nothing at all. The path is defined by its subject matter, plants and place, so theology is left to the practitioner to supply or leave empty.

Does green witchcraft require living in the countryside?

No. Green witchcraft requires a place you return to, not acreage. A green witch in a third-floor flat with six pots, a street tree, and a regular park route has the raw material for a full practice. Rural practice offers more species; urban practice usually produces better knowledge of fewer species, because the small list gets learned to the root.

What is a plant witch, and is it the same as a green witch?

A plant witch is a witch whose craft centers on plants specifically, and the term overlaps heavily with green witch. The distinction practitioners draw is scope: plant witch names the botanical focus alone, while green witch implies the wider land relationship too, including soil, weather, and water. Most people who use one term answer to the other.

How is green witchcraft different from hedge witchcraft and kitchen witchcraft?

Green witchcraft, hedge witchcraft, and kitchen witchcraft share herbs and diverge on where the work happens and what it is for. Green witchcraft is oriented outward to the growing world: the green witch's territory is the garden, the hedgerow, the wood, and the verge, and the core skills are identification, cultivation, harvest timing, and preservation. Hedge witchcraft is oriented across a boundary rather than into a landscape. The hedge in hedge witchcraft is the edge between worlds, and the defining skill is trance journeying, with herbs often serving the journey rather than being the subject. Kitchen witchcraft is oriented inward to the household hearth. Its territory is the stove, the pantry, and the table, and its defining act is putting intention into food that people then eat. A green witch might dry the rosemary, a kitchen witch cooks with it, a hedge witch burns it before going out. The three overlap constantly in real practice and the overlap is not a problem. The useful test is what happens when you subtract the plants. Subtract them from green witchcraft and there is no practice left. Subtract them from hedge witchcraft and the trance work continues. Subtract them from kitchen witchcraft and the cooking, the hospitality, and the hearth tending all survive.

The second difference is temporal. Green witchcraft is organized around the growing year, so its calendar is set by flowering, fruiting, and dormancy, and its rhythm is annual and slow. Kitchen witchcraft runs on a daily and weekly rhythm because meals do. Hedge witchcraft runs on an episodic rhythm set by when a journey is needed. This shows up in the records each keeps: harvest dates and garden notes for the green witch, recipes for the kitchen witch, journey accounts for the hedge witch. A third difference is the source of authority. Green witchcraft treats direct observation of a specific place as the highest authority, above any book, which is why two green witches fifty miles apart hold genuinely different correspondences for the same plant and both are right. Hedge witchcraft locates authority in what was met on the other side, and kitchen witchcraft in what feeds the household well. None of this is doctrine, and plenty of witches run all three. The categories mainly help you work out which skills to build first, and for green witchcraft botany comes before ritual.

Can you practice green witchcraft and kitchen witchcraft at the same time?

Yes, and the combination is common because the pipeline is continuous. Green witchcraft grows and dries the thyme; kitchen witchcraft turns it into soup for someone who is ill. Practitioners who run both usually call themselves green witches with a well-stocked kitchen, since the growing and preserving side takes far more calendar planning.

Is green witchcraft just herbalism with candles?

No. Herbalism aims at physiological effect and judges itself on outcomes in the body. Green witchcraft aims at relationship with plants and land and uses the plants in workings that may have nothing to do with health. Many green witches study herbalism as a companion discipline, and the botanical rigor transfers, but the goals and the success criteria are different.

Why is green witchcraft also called natural witchcraft?

Natural witchcraft is the older, broader term for craft worked with locally available natural material, and green witchcraft is its most plant-focused expression. Some practitioners use natural witchcraft to cover stone, water, bone, and weather work as well, reserving green witch for the chiefly botanical. In common use the two labels are near synonyms.

Which green witch herbs should a beginner learn first?

The starting set of green witch herbs is small, common, and hard to confuse with anything dangerous. Yarrow is the classic first plant, used for boundaries, courage, and divination, and identifiable by its flat white flower heads and finely divided feathery leaves. Mugwort is the dreaming and second-sight herb, silver-backed leaves on a reddish stem, best cut before it flowers. Elder gives two harvests a year, cream blossom in early summer and berries in autumn, and carries strong protective folklore that says you ask the tree before cutting. Rosemary is the memory and cleansing plant and the easiest evergreen to keep alive in a pot. Calendula, the orange pot marigold, is the wound and warmth herb and the best first plant for an infused oil. Chamomile is used for calm, sleep, and gentle money work. Nettle is protection with teeth, plus the best spring green in the hedge. Plantain, the broad-leaved weed in every lawn, is the drawing-out herb. Lavender covers peace and clean sleep. Vervain is the old all-purpose enchanter's herb of European folk magic. Ten plants is enough for years of green witch practice, and knowing ten properly beats owning fifty jars.

The method that works is one plant a month rather than a shelf bought at once. Take a single species, find it living where you can visit it, and watch it through a full cycle: first shoots, leaf shape at three sizes, bud, open flower, seed, die-back, and what the dead stems look like in winter. Sketch it badly, which forces you to look properly, and photograph the same specimen each visit. Smell the crushed leaf and write down what it reminds you of, because your own association will outperform a borrowed correspondence. Only then does the plant go on the drying rack. Twelve months of this gives a green witch ten reliable allies and, more usefully, a method for adding the eleventh. Two cautions belong in the first year. Anything in the carrot family with white umbels needs certainty before you touch it, since poison hemlock and hemlock water dropwort share that silhouette with cow parsley and are lethal. And a familiar-looking plant in an unfamiliar country is a stranger, because common names travel and species do not.

Which green witch herbs grow most easily from seed?

Calendula, borage, chamomile, and nasturtium germinate quickly, tolerate poor soil, and self-seed so reliably that a green witch usually sows them once. Dill is similarly forgiving. Skip lavender and rosemary from seed on a first attempt, since both are slow and erratic; buy those as small plants and take cuttings later.

Which green witch herbs should never be taken internally?

Comfrey contains pyrrolizidine alkaloids and belongs in salves and garden feed rather than tea. Foxglove and monkshood are poisons with no home internal use at all. Wormwood is easy to overdo. A green witch can still work magically with a plant that is unsafe to drink, and keeping those jars on a separate labeled shelf is standard practice.

How many green witch herbs does a working practice actually need?

Ten to fifteen plants cover almost everything a green witch practice asks for, provided each is known well enough to substitute confidently. Large collections accumulate stale material that loses potency and never gets used. A yearly cull helps: anything untouched for two seasons goes to the compost heap and is not replaced.

How does a green witch forage responsibly and legally?

Green witch foraging runs on three fixed rules and one legal check. The first rule is certainty: no plant enters the basket without positive identification of the species, not the genus, from more than one feature. The second is proportion. The widely used guideline is to take no more than one plant in twenty from a stand, and never the first specimen you find or the last one standing, since the first tells you the stand exists and the last is the stand's future. The third is location. Do not harvest from verges sprayed with herbicide, from the bottom two feet of a hedge along a dog-walking path, or from ground next to a busy road, where lead and particulates settle on foliage. The legal check varies by country and is worth knowing precisely. In the United Kingdom, the Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981 makes it an offence to uproot any wild plant without the landowner's permission, while picking leaves, flowers, and fruit from common species for personal use is generally allowed. In the United States, collecting plant material in national parks is broadly prohibited, and several states regulate American ginseng harvest by season and permit. Wild ramps are protected in Quebec and badly depleted in parts of Appalachia.

Beyond law, green witchcraft treats foraging as a transaction with a party who cannot refuse in words, so the practice builds refusal into the process. A green witch approaches, states what they want and why, then waits long enough to notice hesitation in themselves. If the answer feels like no, they walk on, and the discipline of actually walking on is what makes the asking real rather than theatrical. Practically, cut cleanly with snips instead of tearing, take from several plants rather than stripping one, and leave the roots unless the root is what the working needs and the law permits taking it. Many green witches leave something in return. Water poured at the base in dry weather always helps, clearing bindweed off a struggling shrub is better than any token, and carrying out the litter you find in that stand counts more than either. Record date, place, weather, and growth stage, because after three years those notes become a harvest calendar for your particular ground.

What is the one in twenty rule in green witch foraging?

The one in twenty rule means taking at most one plant out of every twenty in a stand, so the population regenerates and other foragers and animals still find food. Green witches apply it per species per site and tighten it for slow-growing plants such as wild garlic in a small wood. For abundant weeds like nettle, the limit is what the stand can regrow in weeks.

How does a green witch ask a plant for permission?

The usual method is to put a hand near the plant, state the request and its purpose plainly, then pause and check your own response before cutting. Green witches read the answer as a felt yes or a distinct reluctance rather than a voice. The asking only means anything if no is a possible outcome, so a refusal means moving to a different plant.

What should a green witch never forage?

Never take anything from the carrot family with white umbels unless you are certain of the species, since poison hemlock and hemlock water dropwort kill. Avoid protected and rare species, anything in a reserve or national park where collecting is prohibited, fungi you cannot name to species, and roots of slow-growing wild perennials.

How do you plan and grow a green witch garden?

A green witch garden is planned around what you actually use, not around a list of magical plants copied from a book. Start with a perennial spine that survives neglect: rosemary, sage, thyme, mint kept in a sunken pot so it cannot run, and lemon balm. Add a self-seeding annual layer that fills gaps and feeds pollinators, with calendula, borage, and chamomile doing most of the work. Include at least one plant you can cut for drying in bulk, since a green witch practice consumes far more mugwort or yarrow than a single specimen provides. If you have room for a shrub, elder earns its space twice a year, and a hawthorn or a rowan gives you a tree relationship in a small footprint. Leave a corner unmown and unweeded on purpose. That wild corner is where nettle, plantain, dandelion, and cleavers appear on their own, and those volunteers are usually the plants a green witch reaches for most. Group by what you do rather than by correspondence, so drying herbs sit together near the path and the wet-loving plants share the shaded end. A garden laid out for actual harvesting gets harvested, and a garden laid out as a diagram gets photographed.

Soil is the part of green witchcraft that beginners skip and experienced practitioners talk about constantly. Compost everything you can, including spent spell material, and treat the heap as the working center of the garden rather than a bin at the back. Comfrey is the classic green witch soil plant: the sterile Bocking 14 cultivar does not seed itself everywhere, and its cut leaves rotted in a bucket of water make a strong, foul-smelling liquid feed. A green witch garden should also hold water somewhere, even a sunken washing-up bowl with a stone ramp, because that brings in frogs, birds, and insects, and the garden stops being a plant collection and becomes a place with residents. Containers work if the pots are bigger than they look like they need to be and the compost is refreshed each spring. The plants that fail indoors want full sun and wind, so do not waste a year keeping lavender on a north-facing ledge.

Can a green witch garden work on a balcony or windowsill?

Yes, with a shorter list and larger pots than most people expect. Mint, thyme, chives, and rosemary hold up well in containers, and calendula flowers freely in a window box. A balcony green witch garden benefits from one deep pot given over to a single plant grown for bulk cutting, plus a shallow dish of water for insects.

What is the wild corner in a green witch garden for?

The wild corner is left unmanaged on purpose so volunteer plants arrive and reveal what the ground wants to grow. Green witches read those volunteers as information about the soil and as the most locally attuned green witch herbs available. It also shelters overwintering insects and yields nettle and cleavers in spring with no cultivation at all.

Should a green witch plant by the moon?

Many green witches sow leafy crops on the waxing moon and root crops on the waning moon, following older agricultural custom, and find the schedule keeps them planting regularly. Green witchcraft does not require it. Soil temperature and last frost date decide germination, so a green witch who plants by the moon should still plant by the thermometer.

How does a green witch mark the turning of the seasons?

Green witchcraft marks the seasons by what the local plants are doing rather than by dates on a calendar, a practice that has a proper name in botany: phenology. A green witch's spring does not begin on a fixed day; it begins when the blackthorn breaks into white flower on bare black wood, when the first snowdrop opens in the churchyard, when the wild garlic smell reaches the path. Summer arrives with the elder blossom, which is also the signal to cut it. Autumn is announced by the first ripe blackberry and closed by the first hard frost that finally sweetens the sloes. Because these signals shift by a week or three each year and differ across a single parish, a green witch who observes them ends up with a calendar that no printed almanac matches, and that mismatch is the useful part. Fixed festivals still get kept, and green witches often anchor to the ones with agricultural content: wassailing apple orchards in January, the old English rule that blackberries should not be picked after Michaelmas at the end of September, harvest at the end of the grain. The rule of thumb is that the plants set the year and the festivals punctuate it.

The practical form this takes is a phenology journal, and it is the single highest-value habit in green witchcraft. Keep one page per year with dated first-events: first snowdrop, first bee, blackthorn in flower, hawthorn in flower, first swift, elder in flower, first blackberry ripe, first fungal flush, first frost, last leaf off the oak. After three years the pattern emerges. After five you can predict, and prediction is when a green witch stops reacting to the season and starts meeting it prepared, with jars washed and labels written before the elder opens. The journal also catches the years that go wrong, which are the instructive ones. A late frost that takes the blossom means no elderberries in September, so autumn stores get planned differently. A green witch who has recorded a drought year knows what the hedge looks like under stress and, more usefully, knows not to harvest from it while it recovers.

How does a green witch keep a phenology journal?

Use one page per year with a fixed list of first-events down the left and the date written beside each as it happens. Keep the list short enough to finish, around twelve entries, and record the site so comparisons stay honest. The value appears in year three, when the columns can be read across.

Does green witchcraft follow the Wheel of the Year?

Many green witches observe the eight festivals of the Wheel of the Year, but green witchcraft does not require them and does not treat the dates as fixed. A green witch is more likely to keep a harvest festival when the harvest is actually in, which may be a fortnight either side of the calendar date. The seasonal observance is descriptive of local conditions rather than prescribed.

Which seasonal harvests anchor the green witch year?

Four harvests structure most temperate green witch years: spring greens such as nettle and wild garlic, early summer elderflower, high summer flower heads including yarrow and calendula, and autumn fruit and root work with elderberry, rosehip, sloe, and hawthorn haw. Each has a narrow window, often under three weeks, which is why a green witch keeps dated records rather than trusting memory.

How does a green witch prepare and preserve plants for use?

A green witch turns fresh plant material into a stable form within hours of harvest, because a wilted bag left in the car is a wasted working. Drying is the default. Bundle stems loosely with string, hang them upside down out of direct sun in a warm, airy place, and keep the temperature under about 95F, since higher heat drives off the volatile oils. Flowers and leaves dry in a week or two and are ready when they crumble rather than bend. Infused oil is the next core skill: fill a dry jar with fully dried plant material, cover it completely with olive or sunflower oil, seal it, and leave it four to six weeks somewhere warm, turning it when you pass. Calendula is the standard first oil. Tinctures use alcohol at 40 percent or above, roughly one part dried herb to five parts spirit, left the same four to six weeks and then strained and bottled dark. Vinegar extracts work for kitchen-safe plants and last around a year. Salves are infused oil melted with beeswax at about one part wax to four parts oil. Every jar gets a label with the species, the part used, the site, and the date.

Storage discipline separates a functioning green witch cupboard from a shelf of expensive dust. Dried leaf and flower hold usable strength for around a year, roots and barks for two or three, and infused oils for about a year unless they smell rancid sooner, in which case they go. Store in glass with tight lids, away from light and the stove, and keep whole rather than powdered, since powder loses aroma fast. Damp is the enemy: material sealed before it is fully dry grows mold in the jar, so leave a bundle an extra few days if you are unsure. Green witchcraft also keeps a hard line between the internal-use shelf and the magic-only shelf, with comfrey, wormwood, and anything unsafe to drink kept separate and labeled as such. Spent jars go to the compost heap rather than the bin. Cull once a year in late winter, when the cupboard is emptiest and the new harvest has not yet arrived.

What is the difference between an infused oil and an essential oil?

An infused oil is a carrier oil that has sat with plant material until it takes on the plant's soluble constituents, and a green witch can make one in a jar on a windowsill. An essential oil is a concentrated volatile extract produced by steam distillation, requires industrial quantities of plant matter, and is far too strong to use undiluted. Green witchcraft leans on infused oils because they are homemade.

How does a green witch dry herbs properly?

Hang loose bundles upside down in a warm, dark, well-ventilated space, or spread single layers on a rack. Keep it under about 95F and out of direct sun, which bleaches color and strips aroma. Material is ready when leaves crumble and stems snap. Green witches strip leaves from stems after drying, not before, and store whole rather than crushed.

What is a simple, and why do green witches use them?

A simple is a preparation made from one plant alone, and green witchcraft favors simples because they teach you what a plant actually does. Working with yarrow on its own for a season gives clearer knowledge than any five-herb blend, since nothing else is contributing. Green witches usually spend early years on simples and only start blending once each component is understood by itself.

How does a green witch build a relationship with a particular place?

Green witchcraft treats one specific place as the long-term partner in the work, and the relationship is built by repetition rather than ritual. Walk the same route weekly for a year in all weather, including the miserable February walks that teach you the most about structure. Learn where the water goes: which corner floods, where the ground stays dry, where the frost sits latest in the morning. Find the boundary of your patch and walk it, since knowing the edge of your territory is old practice and clarifies where your responsibility starts and stops. Learn the residents, not only plants, and note which birds arrive in which month. Green witchcraft often names the presence of a place with the Latin term genius loci, the spirit of the place, and treats it as something to be met on its own terms rather than summoned. Tending is how a green witch pays. Clear the litter from the stand you harvest. Cut the ivy strangling the young hawthorn. Water in drought. Leave the brambles at the back for nesting. A green witch is measured by whether their patch is in better condition after ten years, and that measure is public and physical.

Offerings in green witchcraft are chosen for whether they help rather than for symbolism, which rules out most of what appears in photographs. Water is nearly always right. Compostable food scraps are usually fine away from paths. Do not leave salt, which damages soil, do not leave milk or honey where it draws ants and rodents to a doorway, and do not tie ribbon around a branch, because it stays for years, cuts into growing bark, and traps wildlife. Biodegradable wool tied loosely is the traditional alternative. When a green witch moves house, the practice does not transfer intact, and pretending otherwise wastes a year. Close properly with the old place, take a little soil or a cutting where that is legal, then begin the new site from zero with the same slow method. Rosemary and mint cuttings travel easily and give continuity of plant while the new ground is still a stranger.

What offerings are safe to leave outdoors?

Water is the safest and most useful offering a green witch can leave, particularly in dry spells. Compostable scraps away from paths are acceptable, as is loosely tied undyed wool. Avoid salt, which harms soil, cooked food that draws vermin, coins in streams, and anything synthetic. The best offering in green witchcraft is usually labor.

How does a green witch work with a single tree?

Pick a tree you can reach easily and visit it across a full year, sitting with it ten minutes each time. Learn its bark, its winter bud shape, its flowering week, and what lives in it. Green witches introduce themselves, ask before taking so much as a fallen twig, and take deadfall rather than cutting. The relationship builds over seasons.

What does a green witch do after moving to a new area?

Start again deliberately rather than importing the old correspondences. Buy the regional field guide, walk one route weekly, and identify twenty plants before harvesting anything. Green witchcraft assumes local knowledge is not portable, since flowering times, species, and soil all change. Bring cuttings for continuity, and expect a full year before the new place becomes legible.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is green witchcraft a closed practice that requires initiation?

Green witchcraft is an open practice with no initiation, no lineage, and no governing body. Anyone can learn the plants where they live and begin. What green witchcraft has is a competence standard rather than a membership one: a green witch is expected to identify what they harvest with certainty and to know which parts of a plant are safe. Specific closed traditions sometimes use plant material, and those remain closed, but the plant-centered craft itself is not gatekept.

Do you have to be Wiccan to be a green witch?

No. Green witchcraft is not a branch of Wicca and requires no Wiccan theology, no Rede, and no coven. Many green witches are entirely secular and treat plant work as relationship and skill rather than worship. Others fold green witchcraft into an existing faith. Ann Moura's Green Witchcraft books, published by Llewellyn from 1996, sit inside a witchcraft-religion frame, while Arin Murphy-Hiscock's The Green Witch takes a broadly secular approach. Both describe recognizably the same craft.

What tools does a green witch actually need?

A green witch needs snips, a field guide for the region, glass jars with tight lids, paper labels, string for drying bundles, and a notebook. Everything beyond that is preference. The classic altar tools of ceremonial witchcraft are optional in green witchcraft, and many practitioners never own an athame. What replaces them is inventory: a drying rack, a shelf of labeled jars with harvest dates, and living plants on a plot or a windowsill.

Can green witchcraft be practiced in a city apartment?

Yes, and city green witchcraft is often sharper than rural practice because the plant list is smaller and gets learned properly. Street trees, cemetery yews, canal-bank nettles, and the buddleia coming out of a wall are all real plants with real behavior. Urban green witches usually build the practice around one park or one walking route and track it across years. What a city cannot give is volume, so urban green witch herbs are mostly pot-grown or bought dried.

Are green witch herbs safe to drink or eat?

Some are and some will hurt you, which is why identification matters more in green witchcraft than in any other witchcraft path. Chamomile, nettle, lemon balm, and calendula are widely drunk as teas. Comfrey contains pyrrolizidine alkaloids and is used externally or as garden feed. Foxglove contains cardiac glycosides and is never a tea plant. Mugwort is avoided in pregnancy, and elderberries need cooking. Treat internal use as a separate decision from magical use, and check interactions against any medication.

How long does it take to become a competent green witch?

One full year gets a green witch to genuine competence with a small area, because you cannot know a plant you have met in only one season. A year of watching one hedgerow teaches when the blackthorn flowers on bare wood, when the elder is worth cutting, when the nettles go coarse, and when the hips soften. Most green witches say the second year is when the practice starts working, because that is when prediction becomes possible.

What does a green witch do with plant material after a spell is finished?

Green witchcraft returns spent plant material to the ground, usually to a compost heap or buried at the garden edge. Composting is treated as the correct closing of the loop rather than as disposal, and many green witches say a working is not finished until the material has gone back. Anything with wax, glitter, synthetic ribbon, or foil gets separated out and binned. Material from a banishing is often taken off the property first, to a crossroads or running water.

Try Our Free Tools

Related topics: green witch, green witchcraft, plant witch, green witch herbs, natural witchcraft, green witch garden, green witch practice

What does today hold for your sign?

Enter your birthday for a free reading. No account, no email required.

Free · Instant · No signup needed

Related Articles

Ready to Explore Your Cosmic Path?